Valar Guild Meeting Minutes

November 8, 2026

5:00pm Eastern Daylight Savings Time

Discord: Valar Guild/meeting_place

Before-Meeting

[5:01 AM]Eönwë Valar: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=VhMkrudxLXQ

[4:01 PM]Arien Valar: Hello and aiya all 😄

[4:02 PM]Arien Valar: if anybody cares to appear at some point 🙂

[4:03 PM]Varda: Aiya Arien 🙂

[4:03 PM]Varda: Sandalf is around too. We were just trying to come up with a topic. : )

[4:03 PM]Varda: @Bounder @Guild-friend @Maia @Vala Yay! It's time for the Valar Guild meeting! Chat about gaming, Tolkien, and just say hi.

[4:04 PM]Sandalf13: Aiya All!

[4:04 PM]Falco

[LOTR], : Aiya

[4:04 PM]Varda: Aiya Sandalf : )

[4:04 PM]Varda: Aiya Falco : )

Meeting Begins

[4:05 PM]Varda: Elen sila lumenn' omentielvo!

Membership

[4:05 PM]Varda: Membership:

[4:05 PM]Varda: Eonwe is stuck at work.

[4:05 PM]Earendil: Aiya folks!

[4:05 PM]Varda: Aiya to the morning star!

[4:05 PM]Varda: We are lucky to have Arien, Sandalf, Falco, and Earendil. Thank you for popping in!

[4:06 PM]Varda: Any membership news we'd like to pass along?

Web News

[4:07 PM]Varda: Nothing up for Tolkien this past week.

[4:07 PM]Varda: I do try to keep up with the transcripts, not behind at the moment. ; )

Gaming News

[4:07 PM]Varda: Gaming:

[4:08 PM]Varda: Pallando is not online at the moment for EVE Online, but maybe later.

[4:08 PM]Varda: Eonwe is present in Discord sort of, but probably more in a looking in when he can mode.

[4:09 PM]Varda: O wow. He put up the Gaming news since my last check!

[4:09 PM]Pallando-Valar: I'm here, Aiya. 🙂

[4:10 PM]Varda: Pallando! Aiya!

EVE Online:

[4:10 PM]Varda: Would you like to bring up Eve news? Perfect time for it.

[4:10 PM]Pallando-Valar: Really the only thing to mention is that the patch notes dropped Friday. (For Fractured Skies Expansion Notes.)

[4:11 PM]Varda: That's important. And that ship may be hard to patch.

[4:11 PM]Pallando-Valar: Some extra details about what's coming Tuesday, but nothing really newsworthy. Lots of stuff still to be figured out when the patch goes live.

[4:11 PM]Varda: And then refigured.

[4:11 PM]Pallando-Valar: More news next week after we get our teeth into it.

[4:11 PM]Varda: Should be interesting! Toothmarks and all.

[4:14 PM]Treebeard: Hello 🙂

[4:14 PM]Varda: Aiya Fangorn!

World of Warcraft:

[4:15 PM]Varda: World of Warcraft:

[4:15 PM]Varda: This week's bonus event: Midnight Dungeons.

[4:15 PM]Varda: This week's PvP Brawl: Warsong Scramble.

[4:15 PM]Varda: The Darkmoon Faire is this week.

World of Warcraft: Forever:

[4:15 PM]Varda: WoW: Forever:

[4:16 PM]Varda: WoW Forever is live and here's a couple more blogs about it.

[4:16 PM]Varda: (And our Eowyn-V has it up right now!)

[4:17 PM]Varda: WoW: Forever — What’s New and What Feels Familiar

[4:17 PM]Varda: Explore WoW: Forever with a Gamepad

[4:18 PM]Varda: WoW: Forever – Watch Forging Forever

[4:18 PM]Varda: See WoW Weekly for anything not mentioned above.

[4:19 PM]Varda: Check out this week's hotfixes for both WoW retail and WoW Forever.

Diablo Immortal:

[4:20 PM]Varda: Diablo Immortal:

[4:20 PM]Varda: The new content update is out.

[4:20 PM]Varda: (Please don't tell us it's Gandalf.)

Diablo II:

[4:21 PM]Varda: Diablo clones, Cow Level portals and boosted magic find: See how D2 Resurrected is celebrating Diablo's 30th anniversary.

Overwatch:

[4:21 PM]Varda: Overwatch:

[4:22 PM]Varda: A new blog is out: Reign of Talon – S5 Midcycle Sets Up the Showdown.

Hearthstone:

[4:22 PM]Varda: Hearthstone:

[4:22 PM]Varda: Patch 37.0.2 is live.

StarCraft 2:

[4:23 PM]Varda: StarCraft 2:

[4:23 PM]Varda: Valarites that I know of this past week that gamed in SC2: Eowyn, Fangorn, Faramir, Varda

Lord of the Rings Online:

[4:24 PM]Varda: Lord of the Rings Online:

[4:24 PM]Varda: Update 50.1 is live.

[4:25 PM]Varda: Filbert Fig is back.

[4:26 PM]Varda: Easiest way to find Filbert is at Bree's boar fountain. I trust you got Lalia's handy return, that takes you right by it. I try to get it on all my characters, worth it.

[4:26 PM]Varda: Filbert might not be, but Lalia's return is. : )

[4:27 PM]Varda: The schedule for the Angmar and Mordor Legendary Worlds has been updated.

[4:27 PM]Varda: https://www.lotro.com/news/lotro-angmar-mordor-schedule-update-en

[4:27 PM]Varda: The Virtue Traits level raised to 104. Don't forget to check yours!

[4:28 PM]Varda: Also, all 160's, they gave us a new reforge for Wolves of Mordor.

[4:28 PM]Varda: Code: WARMFEELING For a Battle Potion of Restoration good through November 12th.

[4:28 PM]Varda: LotRO news: https://www.lotro.com/home#homeNews

[4:29 PM]Varda: I didn't quite finish making it through the LotRO branches, but here's what I have so far, and it should be updated in a bit.

[4:29 PM]Varda: Kinmates that came into our LotRO branches this past week:

Peregrin branch:

Glamdring branch:

Meriadoc branch:

Angmar branch:

Mordor branch:

[4:30 PM]Varda: Any other gaming news anyone would like to pass along?

[4:31 PM]Varda: Looks as if Arien is also in WoW: Forever. : )

[4:31 PM]Varda: Gaming news done, then.

[4:31 PM]Varda: Any other membership news?

[4:32 PM]Varda: My birthday is this week, the 10th. Elwing plans to come over so you may be seeing her in LotRO the next couple of days. : )

[4:32 PM]Earendil: HAPPY EARLY BIRTHDAY!

[4:33 PM]Varda: hehe - thanks!

[4:33 PM]Varda: On to

Tolkien Discussion:

[4:33 PM]Varda: Tolkien!

[4:33 PM]Earendil: 😆

[4:33 PM]Varda: Does anyone have a topic we might chew on for a bit?

[4:33 PM]Varda: A question? A quote you like?

[4:34 PM]Varda: Ok, you all get to flip open a Tolkien book and spot a paragraph. It's almost sure to be interesting, so get ready to type!

[4:34 PM]Varda: Do tell us the book and chapter first!

[4:35 PM]Varda: Oh, a fun sentence:

[4:35 PM]Varda: TT, "Flotsam and Jetsam""

[4:36 PM]Varda: Merry said:

[4:36 PM]Varda: "But I hope that the Ents may have found time to brew some of their draughts from the mountain-springs, and we shall see Gandalf's beard curling when he returns."

[4:37 PM]Varda: Earendil, you were trying to type? Go ahead. : )

[4:38 PM]Sandalf13: Happy Birthday, Varda!!! ☺️

[4:38 PM]Varda: Thank you. : )

[4:38 PM]Varda: Will be 73.

[4:38 PM]Sandalf13: A wonderful age!!!

[4:38 PM]Varda: (Eons)

[4:38 PM]Varda: Aye!

[4:40 PM]Earendil: Well I've been thinking the last day or so, and joking with roommates reminded me, how much I would love to know just more in general about bilbos journey to Rivendell and his time there outside of the quest in the big three, so to speak. Like how soon did his health begin to fade, how easy or hard was the journey to Rivendell this time.

[4:40 PM]Earendil: Just basically...I would've loved to see more of my favorite hobbit.

[4:40 PM]Earendil: Just me on that one guys?

[4:41 PM]Varda: Everyone wants more of Bilbo!

[4:42 PM]Varda: Books have to focus a bit, like on the main subject, unfortunately. But that's what short stories are good for!

[4:42 PM]Sandalf13: That is a wonderful idea! We do not learn much at all about Bilbo's second trip to Imladris, although Tolkien does comment that he traveled to the Lonely Mountain as well. Did he first stop at Rivendell on the way there and then return again? Did he revisit his old friend Thranduil? Who knows?

[4:42 PM]Treebeard: It's not every year that we hear of a verified 111 birthday 🙂

[4:43 PM]Varda: Bilbo's health would have started fading from the time he left the One Ring behind.

[4:43 PM]Varda: He already felt "stretched".

[4:44 PM]Varda: I would bet Bilbo visited Thranduil. Good mention!

[4:44 PM]Treebeard: Didn't Frodo hang around the shire another 54 years before heading out to destroy the ring?... unlike what the movie made it seem

[4:44 PM]Varda: But it would mean going on past Riv and then back. (Note: missed the mention of going to the Lonely Mountain. That would mean Mirkwood and Thranduil are on the way there.)

[4:44 PM]Varda: Aye, Frodo didn't set off right away at all.

[4:45 PM]Varda: So Bilbo might have gone on a short trip from Riv to Mirkwood and back again. Could have been hazardous if he didn't wait until after the War was over.

[4:45 PM]Varda: He would have had companions in any case.

[4:45 PM]Earendil: At 111, who on that journey would be alive to greet him? The dwarves and elves sure, but would Bard or any of his people who met him still remain? Also, I know it was at least 17 years after Gandalf left (the hunt for gollum right?). Oh these points are awesome!

[4:46 PM]Earendil: I wonder if he inspired statues...

[4:47 PM]Sandalf13: For me, one of the most dramatic moments in the entire LoTR: "Then passing through the door he (Gandalf) took Faramir and laid him on the bier on which he had been brought, and which had now been set in the porch. Denethor followed him, and stood trembling, looking with longing on the face of his son. And for a moment, while all were silent and still, watching the Lord in his throes, he wavered."

[4:47 PM]Sandalf13: Sort of like Gollum looking with sadness on longing on the faces of the sleeping Sam and Frodo, before Sam awakes and chastises him. What might have happened if Sam had not reacted the way he did?

[4:49 PM]Earendil: Maybe the end of the world if he hadn't bit the ring off Frodos finger. Unless he might've done it heroically? Hero gollum?

[4:49 PM]Earendil: Someone call marvel loki...

[4:49 PM]Earendil: ...I'd watch that timeline.

[4:49 PM]Earendil: 🤔

[4:50 PM]Varda: 🙂

[4:50 PM]Varda: The moments where time shivered, waiting.

[4:52 PM]Treebeard: I'd say "Ring thief" to Gollum - selfish worship of the ring of power that kept him alive for those many years in the orc caverns, etc. He died as a oath breaker solidified by the ring itself. Bad Gollum, but happy for a few moments before swish into vapor.

[4:57 PM]Varda: Ohh, interesting thought, Sandalf. The volcano was chatting with Caradhras and they came to a failsafe agreement! ; )

[4:58 PM]Earendil: I've been reading lately, that's a big "what else". Scary thought.

[4:58 PM]Varda: Aye Fangorn. Only a part of Sauron's power and malice was in the One Ring, and it was working hard to return and be whole.

[4:58 PM]Sandalf13: Bottom line: good thing the Ring got remelted in basalt.

[4:59 PM]Varda: Aye

[4:59 PM]Treebeard: yes, good conclusion for a long yet well planned saga

[5:00 PM]Varda: Tolkien, the Master. : )

[5:00 PM]Varda: The One Book.

[5:00 PM]Sandalf13: And I could see some modern day geologist prospecting in a basalt-rich environment, and finding a small bleb of gold...gold is almost NEVER found in basalt. Take it from me.

[5:00 PM]Earendil: Mm hm. Still, it's the very best of tales that leave you imagining years on...

[5:02 PM]Earendil: Geology knowledge as well? Your many facets as an interesting person are as great as some quests, friend.

[5:02 PM]Sandalf13: To my way of thinking, that is what separates Tolkien from Martin: staying power. The Game of Thrones is good reading, interesting, and involved, but I do not believe it will last the same way that the LoTR will.

[5:02 PM]Treebeard: Yay! Gold covered basalt from vaporized and condensed ring of power...basalt with bad intentions

[5:03 PM]Varda: hah!

[5:03 PM]Sandalf13: heh heh heh

[5:03 PM]Earendil: Breaking bad, basalt edition!

[5:03 PM]Varda: hehehe

[5:04 PM]Arien Valar: top word game, Earendi. 😄

[5:04 PM]Earendil: 🧐

[5:04 PM]Varda: heh

[5:04 PM]Earendil: Thank you very much!

[5:04 PM]Sandalf13: !!!

[5:04 PM]Varda: hammer taps basalt-covered hammerpad

[5:05 PM]Varda: golden tinnnnng

[5:05 PM]Sandalf13: No good unless it is your geologic hammer!!!

[5:05 PM]Varda: (We are keeping it secret and safe.)

[5:05 PM]Arien Valar: if you move the re from breaking to bad you get "baking bread" 😄

After-meeting:

[5:05 PM]Varda: After-meeting!

[5:05 PM]Varda: Free chat! Including continuing our current thread. : )

[5:05 PM]Sandalf13: Is this a thread?

[5:06 PM]Sandalf13: Threads don't hold up long in magma...

[5:06 PM]Varda: Chat, if you like.

[5:06 PM]Earendil: A good conversation, don't know about sewing though...

[5:06 PM]Treebeard: Great meeting. Good gaming to all. Namarie!

[5:07 PM]Sandalf13: Namarie, Treebeard! Enjoy a good week!

[5:07 PM]Earendil: Namarie!

[5:07 PM]Arien Valar: Namarie all you lovely people 😄

[5:07 PM]Varda: Wired thread structure in rock

[5:07 PM]Varda: Namarie!

[5:07 PM]Sandalf13: Namarie Arien! Enjoy some sunshine!

[5:07 PM]Earendil: Awnser...ELVES...

[5:07 PM]Varda: ☼

[5:08 PM]Earendil: Namarie Arien!

[5:08 PM]Sandalf13: I believe that it is a fracture into which some late magmatic fluids were injected.

[5:08 PM]Sandalf13: Under extremely high pressure.

[5:08 PM]Varda: and as promised: (The finished LotRO branch activity was moved from here and added to the correct place in Gaming, deleting here.)

[5:09 PM]Earendil: Huh. Never thought it before, but I bet those kinds of forces make cool patterns...

[5:09 PM]Sandalf13: Ya sure ya betcha!

[5:09 PM]Earendil: (The geology, but the list above makes cool patterns as well!)

[5:11 PM]Sandalf13: Most of the worlds great gemstones are found in granite pegmatites (late-stage magmatic fluids) that are injected into rock then slowly cool.

[5:11 PM]Varda: I want to see that hypodermic.

[5:11 PM]Varda: /duck

[5:12 PM]Earendil: So the granite is the right resistance/fracture pattern (if that's even the right words) to create the space for that kind of...mineralization?

[5:12 PM]Earendil: Probably not even English words there...

[5:13 PM]Earendil: Man I should learn more about geology.

[5:13 PM]Varda: We can always borrow other words and make them our own, as any proper English does. ; )

[5:14 PM]Varda: Granite is the main one for some reason?

[5:14 PM]Sandalf13: Here we see a granitic pegmatite (coarser grained stuff, white) injected into a finer-grained rock...looks like granodiorite to me, could be andesite as well.

[Discord image.

[5:16 PM]Sandalf13: There are all sorts of pegmatites in this world of ours: in basaltic areas, andesitic areas, and granitic terranes. But the best sources of gemstones and rare-earth minerals/elements are the late stage pegmatites that occur in granites throughout the world. The oddball elements have an affinity for lighter, silicon-rich and aluminum-rich granite melts.

[5:16 PM]Earendil: Geology words might make perfect spell language, it seems.

[5:17 PM]Earendil: Aluminum? In granite or just occurring together at high rate?

[5:17 PM]Sandalf13: If you are interested, Earendil, I do a much better job of explaining some of this in my Chapter Three : The Geology of Middle-earth.

[5:18 PM]Earendil: Okay yeah you've struck my interst with an Elvin blade here.

[5:18 PM]Varda: Geology of Middle-earth"

[5:18 PM]Earendil: Thanks varda!

[5:18 PM]Varda: My pleasure. : )

[5:19 PM]Sandalf13: As an ore, aluminum is found mainly in lateritic deposits. However, Aluminum is the FOURTH most abundant element in the Earth's crust, and is commonly found in compounds within granite. Basalts have considerably LESS aluminum than granite...

[5:19 PM]Sandalf13: OSiAlFeCaNaKMg....sorry....Al is number THREE, not four. Iron (Fe) is number four. I Must be getting old.

[5:20 PM]Varda: You caught yourself quickly, so not old in a bad way!

[5:20 PM]Varda: Old in a picked up tons if info way.

[5:21 PM]Earendil: 🤣 if by getting old, you mean knowledgeable as Gandalf I'm in agreement. So is granite a paizo electric stone? I've only heard some are and was curious.

[5:21 PM]Sandalf13: Funny thing about the above saying: I thought I would be unique, and I picked "Osial" as my first attempt at a user i.d. for Gmail. Already taken! Then I tried SialFe! Already taken. AlFe? Already taken. So I landed up with Fecanak1 as my gmail.com user i.d.

[5:22 PM]Sandalf13: Must have been a hell of a lot of geochemists thinking about the same thing for an i.d.!! hehe heh😆 😆

[5:23 PM]Sandalf13: Quartz is piezo-electric. That is why we have quartz watches.

[5:23 PM]Earendil: So it is in reference to conductive quality. Not granite though?

[5:23 PM]Sandalf13: There are a few other piezo electric minerals out there, but quartz is the cheapest, and the best, and the most readily available.

[5:25 PM]Sandalf13: That is an idea Varda! Instead of a hammer pad, get yourself a piezo electric mineral and make a few sparks when you end the meeting! 😆

[5:25 PM]Sandalf13: Granite is not piezo electric.

[5:25 PM]Earendil: I will attempt in earnest to make something cool with that idea. As soon as I finish 100 other projects...

[5:26 PM]Earendil: 😮‍💨

[5:27 PM]Earendil: Tired bear need hibernate...Namarie folks, and I'm gonna kick through that chapter with notes, I've a notion it might inspire regarding my hunt for troll sources!

[5:28 PM]Sandalf13: Namarie, Earendil! And I too shall bid our remaining Valarites a fond adieu! Lots to do to get ready for the week. I am traveling to Florida on THursday to visit my older cousin and his wife in Tampa. Might miss the meeting next SUnday due to traveling back to Thornton from Tampa.

[5:29 PM]Earendil: Safe travels! Promise I'm namarie-ing now...

[5:29 PM]Earendil: 😆

[5:29 PM]Varda: Namarie!

[9:30 PM]Ar-Pharazon-V: Aiya, reading up!

[9:35 PM]Ar-Pharazon-V: Happy early birthday Varda!

[9:47 PM]Ar-Pharazon-V: Iron as only the fourth most common element caught me by surprise, until I realized you specified the crust, and not the entire planet.

[9:47 PM]Ar-Pharazon-V: you being Sandalf

[9:51 PM]Ar-Pharazon-V: And I still wonder if any active volcano might work for Ring-melting, as no others showed on the maps we've seen, or if there was some specific property of Orodruin related to Sauron's power. The fact that the Ring was forged there seems mostly symbolic.

[9:57 PM]Varda: Symbolism and magic work together.

[9:58 PM]Ar-Pharazon-V: That is true.

[November 9, 2026]

[8:05 AM]Ar-Pharazon-V: Personal gaming report:

[8:06 AM]Ar-Pharazon-V: For (non)flashgaming a newer game, not sure if I've linked it before, but it had a badge of the day this week, so here it is 🙂

[8:07 AM]Ar-Pharazon-V: Cluck Control is a grid-based puzzle game where you have to guide a chicken to the goal tile in each field.

[8:08 AM]Ar-Pharazon-V: The chicken runs ahead without thinking, but can be blocked and turned when there's only one path to the side open. There's also other obstacles to place and to overcome. Use the tools you've been given in each level, it can be quite complicated 🙂

[8:52 AM]Ar-Pharazon-V: Blizzard gaming:

[8:54 AM]Ar-Pharazon-V: Hearthstone:

[Level 45 on the reward track now, getting some more gold and expansion cards.

[8:55 AM]Ar-Pharazon-V: Got enough gold to buy a new skin, and there were a whole bunch available this time around. Frontiersman Uther looked the most interesting, for paladin.

[8:56 AM]Ar-Pharazon-V: I also actually opened some packs, for the few days I remembered to do so, and got a rogue legendary, The Unknowable One.

[8:58 AM]Ar-Pharazon-V: New Darkmoon Faire up, N'Zoth pet as centerpiece. Now there's 3 DMFs at once, for the first time. I suppose there's no need to be a limit of how many are up at once.

[8:58 AM]Ar-Pharazon-V: My free reward was a signature card, Malicious Presence.

[9:01 AM]Ar-Pharazon-V: Reign of the Black Empire quest event completed, with a Ritual N'zoth priest skin as final reward. Apparently we've now explored Nyalotha? With story more concentrated in the Journey feature, I suppose it's ok if the "event tracks" as they are now called, are rather more vague.

[9:05 AM]Ar-Pharazon-V: As for the journey, the K'thir priest has now taught us about N'Zoth, who specializes in secrecy and subtle corruption. To better understand him, we've found scrolls, which led us to a dangerous temple and a Pendant of Corruption, a sacred relic. Placing this on an altar should grant us a true blessing of N'zoth. Which is apparently a card pack 😄

[9:06 AM]Ar-Pharazon-V: Finally, the brawl is The Void Singularity! At the end of your turn, all your minions are crushed into one void elemental with the total attack and health stats of your minions.

[9:06 AM]Ar-Pharazon-V: Since everything's going to die before it does very much, an easy way through is to use stuff with powerful deathrattles, such as new summons you can actually use next turn 🙂

[9:08 AM]Ar-Pharazon-V: Warcraft Rumble:

[No new acquisitions.

[9:08 AM]Ar-Pharazon-V: Login calendar for november is getting to the better stuff, as is the pvp reward track, and I now have more than 10% of the gold I need for remaining legendary cores.

[9:09 AM]Ar-Pharazon-V: Hallow's End is over, but Pilgrim's Bounty is coming in just over a week, surely with more mad quests and rewards! If I remember correctly, this one involves a giant turkey boss 😄

[9:10 AM]Ar-Pharazon-V: WoW:

[9:12 AM]Ar-Pharazon-V: More raiding, getting close to end of heroic raid. Personally I finally got the achievement for a kill on all raidbosses, regardless of difficulty, so that's nice.

[9:13 AM]Ar-Pharazon-V: Weekly quest is for mythic dungeons, where I'm just doing Ruby Life Pools this season. It feels short and I know the place. I couldn't just find groups for m0 though, so I did a +2 keystone for the first time this expansion. Quick enough, though the increased stats were already noticeable.

[9:14 AM]Ar-Pharazon-V: Storywise I finally made some progress, saving a village from snake people, and then fighting across the skybridge. That bloody isle is finally on the horizon!

[9:15 AM]Ar-Pharazon-V: And in Forever, I logged in on my druid, got him guilded, and fixed up camera and interface. I'll try to weave his questing between my retail and D4 questing.

[9:15 AM]Ar-Pharazon-V: Not enough hours in the day ♪

[9:17 AM]Ar-Pharazon-V: And finally, the D&D/WoW crossover arrived! Got booklets and maps and all sorts of lore goodies, even though I probably won't actually be playing D&D with them. But also in-game goodies! A dragon mount called Black Malice, an Eyestalker pet which is I think a unique model, and a mimic chest toy and decor. Apparently you can hide in the chest 🙂

[9:20 AM]Ar-Pharazon-V: And that's my report for the week!

[9:20 AM]Ar-Pharazon-V: Namarie 🙂

[4:11 PM]Varda: Thanks, Phar. 🙂

top